Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate This Thread
Hop To
#4389267 - 11/12/17 08:37 AM With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda  
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
FsFOOT Offline
Member
FsFOOT  Offline
Member

Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
Just read this book. https://www.harpercollins.com.au/9780061984945/with-wings-like-eagles/
[Linked Image]
Printed 2009. The book is short and to the point. Only 300 pages text. Nice cover with Spits and some classic photos. Reviewed by moi.

The first half of the book basically points out an overview with some detail of the politics, players, and policies leading up to the BoB / post effects of the Dunkirk.
Points out failures of a GB policy for prewar France support in airpower, etc. ie. lack of foresight etc.
Differents of view in the RAF old guard way of thought and the soon to be proven superior strategy of Dowding.

A main focus of the book is the role and strategy and innovations of
Air Marshall Chief Sir Hugh Dowding
Quote

"To him the people of Britain and of the free world owe largely the way of life and the liberties that they enjoy today"

(Since he was the man who practically developed the intergrated use of radar / spotter intelligence and air control dispatch in what we would call today "real time". As well as forming the flexible 4 major Groups of the Fighter Command coverage for the UK defenses, creating the command structures to the local bases.
And his strategy to not reveal the strength of the RAF at any given time ("..hiding his hand like a poker player" as is pointed out many times) as well as hiding of both the value of the radar technology and the whole 'real time' plotting from the Germans was indeed masterful.
The whole 'Kit and Kaboodle' really.
In short; The RAF in the BOB we are all familiar with, right down to the fields and scrambles is really pratically all the work of Sir Dowding... etc.


The author, both an ex-RAF pilot (correction He served in the Royal Air Force - doing intelligence work in Germany) and decorated heroe of the later Hungarian Revolution does not over-indulge in this at all.
Nor is it a fanboy book or anything of the kind.

If the first part of the book is a bit long winded, my patience was rewarded later.

The second half of the book goes right into details as the timeline starts to unfold right into the Battle.

Both scholarly work by the author in details of the aircraft numbers and the isolation to point of critial lesser known details is apparent.
During the battle key days are given sizeable details.

The author then shows his hand in what was, to me, riveting page turners at times, as well as personal details of some events, pilots while not losing the overall naration without losing the focus of how the strategies and developments, incidents, historical facts and reverses of the German actions / strategies plays out.

After reading some of these I practically got re-excited about EAW and any BOB WWII air related games, etc.
Because you can really see how this Campaign was like a big game and the timing and pieces, strategies, tactics and extant / outside factors, even the weather all played out.

It was by no means a sure win on any given day for either side no matter specifically the numbers of strength of the planned attacks by the Germans. (Well at least until later in the battle where the Germans loses were equal to or less than the RAF fighters and pilots specifically. . When the RAF was soon about to lose the battle really until the Germans changed strategy at Hitler's request to bomb London freely in retailiation for the raid on Berlin by Churchill's orders.)

In fact the book points out that really the number of (available) pilots of both the RAF and the Germans was about 1000 to1300 going in. And the number of single-seat fighter aircraft (of relevance) we about the same also.

The book specific numbers and references several other references authoritative.

It points out the specific number of aircraft available for sevice in the battle, as apposed to theorectical numbers, rosters, etc,
Also debunks several myths per foriegn pilots in the battle etc.

My review getting to long here's an except that gets to the point; (Chapter 7)

Quote

"..By the end of June,Dowding had just over 1.300 fighter pilots. Most of them were British, and few of them had any combat experience. During the course of the battle Fighter Command would also draw on 56 carrier pilots from Royal Navy's Fleet Air Arm, as well as a mixed-bag of 21 Australians, 102 New Zealanders, 90 Canadians (including a few americans - border crossers), 21 South Africans, 2 Rhodesians, 1 Jamaican, nine Irish volunteers, 7 Americans, 141 Poles, 86 Czechs, 29 Belgians, 13 Free French avaiators, and one Palestine Jew."

(and)
Quote

"..Although it is usual to portray the Battle of Britain as a kind of.. David and Goliath.. The reality is that.. (aside from the nearly 1000 serviceable bombers avialable to the Germans.. August 10,1940. ) the number of single-engine fighters.. available..

805 serviceable Bf 109's vs Dowding's 749 Hurricanes and Spitfires..

...the additional 224 Bf110's ..far from being an asset, would themselves require the protection of the single-engine Bf 109's to survive in air combat..

(and)
Quote

..In pilot strength, ...
...The actual number of German Fighter Pilots available was roughly similar..



sorry, tired just now have to have another go round of this another day...
S!

addendum
also see; SimHQ post - Greatest Book on the Battle of Britain



Last edited by FsFOOT; 02/17/19 08:33 AM. Reason: added pic and link
Inline advert (2nd and 3rd post)

#4390412 - 11/19/17 07:59 AM Re: With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda [Re: FsFOOT]  
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
FsFOOT Offline
Member
FsFOOT  Offline
Member

Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
Interesting facts / quirks of history noted in the book;

Dowding was almost retired long before the BoB and even the entire build-up that he managed.
Originally expected to retire in 1938, then June 1939, then March, 1940 and later July 14, 1940 when his appointment as CiC of Fighter Command ran out.
In August, at the height of the battle, he was put on notice that it would be extended to November only.
Finally after the battle November 25, 1940 he retired.

Hard for me to imagine that the man we needed most at the time was short-sightedly almost forced to retire during this most critical period!

..on to the review;


The book points out that Dowding was practically the sole architect of the right way to build up the Fighter Command assets and strategy. And the way that Fighter Command ran the command and control / the strategy of Dowding eventually prevailed.
As well as his foresight in the whole build up long before 1940.

Quote

"Throughout 1936 and 1937 Dowding painstakingly built the foundations of his strategy to protect England, putting pieces together like those of a gigantic three-dimensional jigsaw puzzle. Almost as soon as he took command he sent in a modest request for (L)500 to construct his Operations Room at Bentley Priory.. to give him something that had existed before only in the form of sets for a futuristic film like 'Things to Come'..
..in the mid 1930's it was the only things of its kind in the world.

Dowding moved fast, transforming the ballroom of Bentley priory into a big, crowded amphitheatre for a new kind of war, and using the graceful rotunda next door for the necessary teleprinters and switchboards.
On the floor of the ballroom he built an enormous irregularly shaped table to represent the southern coast of England, the English Channel, and the northern coast of the continent, 'from Edinburgh to the French coast, to Cherbourg, and from the Welsh border to the East of Belgium.'

The surface of the map table was divided into squares each one marked and indentified with a letter of the alphabet. This was the 'Fitter Room.' Around the table would sit or stand a dozen or so young airmen and airwomen.. each supplied with a box of counters, rather like those used in playing chemin de fer or roulette in a casino, and a long stick with a bar at the end like that used by the croupier at the roulette table. Each 'filter' wore earphones, and some of them also wore a microphone suspended around the neck.

Above the filterers was built a 'gallery' where the whole table could be observed from above by the officers charged with warning each Fighter Group of the situation as it developed on the board below, as well as by the naval liason officer, a senoir Royal Artillery officer with a direct line to the headquarters of the anti-aircraft gunners and searchlight operators, and officers linked by direct lines to the Observer Corps, the police, the fire services, and those in charge of sounding the air-raid alarms. the filters recieved information as it came out of the operation room in each Fighter Group, from the radar plotters on the coast, and from the observerson the ground;

and once an enemy raid had been identified, they set up an identifying marker for it, showing its present position, the projected course of the raid, the height, and the number of enemy aircraft it contained, moving the marker with their long sticks as it progressed from the enemy coast, across the Channel or the North Sea, and toward one of the four Fighter Groups, each defending its own 'Sector.'...

..Behind the table, on the wall facing the gallery, there was another big board with rows of colored lights on it, known inevitably as the 'Tote Board.'..that displayed readiness of each fighter squadron (on standby, available, refueling and rearming, or in the air).
A large prominently placed clock, with time segments marked in different colors, allowed the filteres to instantly plot the exact position of a raid - for everything would be taking place in real time at 200 or 300 miles an hour, and the fighter squadrons in the air would need to know where the enemy they were approaching was now, not not where it had been two or three minutes before. Equally important, they would need to be 'scrambled' in time to climb, if possble, to a height above the enemy's and to attack from behind.

(The Spitfire, when it came into service in 1938, would require just under eleven minutes to climb to a height of 25,000 feet, and complex and precise mathematical calculations would need to be made in split seconds to bring fighter squadrons to exactly where they had to be for a sucessful interception.)

..Dowding's genius was to have built a system that economized on his fighter strength - there would be no wasteful 'patrols' of fighter aircraft searching for, or trying to intercept at random, groups of enemy aircraft, and losing sight of them in the clouds.
Dowding was not a romantic, at least on the subject of air warfare - he sought efficiency.
The fighter squadrons nearest to each raid as it passed through their Group could be scrambled at the last possible moment to attack the enemy as he drew close to them; this proceedure would also help to conserve the amount of fuel they had for combat at full power. in effect the system acted like a multiplyer to Fighter Command's strength."


and the Germans were completely unaware that it existed!

Last edited by FsFOOT; 11/19/17 08:02 AM. Reason: [i]25,000 feet[/i]
#4390983 - 11/23/17 03:02 AM Re: With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda [Re: FsFOOT]  
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
FsFOOT Offline
Member
FsFOOT  Offline
Member

Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
Correction, my mistake:
Although he served in the RAF he was not a pilot.
He served in the Royal Air Force - doing intelligence work in Germany.

Last edited by FsFOOT; 11/23/17 03:16 AM.
#4390984 - 11/23/17 03:15 AM Re: With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda [Re: FsFOOT]  
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
FsFOOT Offline
Member
FsFOOT  Offline
Member

Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
Also I failed to point out;

The main strategy of Dowding for the BoB victory was that he did not need to 'win' per se, that is 'defeat the Luftwaffe'.
He clearly understood that RAF Fighter Command needed to simply 'hold out' until sometime in September and the battle would be over for the year 1940.

Since the weather in the English Channel would change. It would be into the storm season.
The Germans would be practically suicidal to launch an invasion force after the first week of September since at any time a storm could come through and wreck the entire operation.

The author cites that even in the planning of the 1944 Normandy Invasion May was considered ideal, June at the latest.
July would have been considered too late for the risk of storms in the North Atlantic or Channel. Nevermind August or September!

Last edited by FsFOOT; 11/23/17 03:17 AM. Reason: grammar
#4391952 - 11/30/17 12:35 AM Re: With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda [Re: FsFOOT]  
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 5,503
Pooch Offline
Hotshot
Pooch  Offline
Hotshot

Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 5,503
Orlando, FL
"Correction, my mistake:
Although he served in the RAF he was not a pilot.
He served in the Royal Air Force - doing intelligence work in Germany."

Are you talking about Dowding, here? He most certainly was a pilot. Flew during the First World War. Moved up quickly and was given command of a squadron and before the war was over he had a temporary rank of General. He continued to be promoted in the years beween the wars, and in 1936 was given command of the newly formed Fighter Command. A posting that would never had gone to someone who wan't even a pilot. I've never heard of him doing intelligence work in Germany. Maybe I misunderstood and you are writing about someone else.
Peter Townsend's book, Duel of Eagles is the best thing I've ever read on the Battle of Britain.


"From our orbital vantage point, we observe an earth without borders, full of peace, beauty and magnificence, and we pray that humanity as a whole can imagine a borderless world as we see it, and strive to live as one in peace."
Astronaut William C. McCool RIP, January 29, 2003 - Space Shuttle Columbia

#4391986 - 11/30/17 06:51 AM Re: With Wings Like Eagles - Michael Korda [Re: FsFOOT]  
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
FsFOOT Offline
Member
FsFOOT  Offline
Member

Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 602
Sorry, not Dowding, the author Michael Korda

The book is a bit short as I said previously, however the Bibliography is 3 pages and cites most major works on the subject and even the aircraft.


Moderated by  RacerGT 

Quick Search
Recent Articles
Support SimHQ

If you shop on Amazon use this Amazon link to support SimHQ
.
Social


Recent Topics
Dickey Betts was 80
by Rick_Rawlings. 04/19/24 01:11 AM
Exodus
by RedOneAlpha. 04/18/24 05:46 PM
Grumman Wildcat unique landing gear
by Coot. 04/17/24 03:54 PM
Peter Higgs was 94
by Rick_Rawlings. 04/17/24 12:28 AM
Whitey Herzog was 92
by F4UDash4. 04/16/24 04:41 PM
Anyone can tell me what this is?
by NoFlyBoy. 04/16/24 04:10 PM
10 Years ago MV Sewol
by wormfood. 04/15/24 08:25 PM
Pride Of Jenni race win
by NoFlyBoy. 04/15/24 12:22 AM
It's Friday: grown up humor for the weekend.
by NoFlyBoy. 04/12/24 01:41 PM
OJ Simpson Dead at 76
by bones. 04/11/24 03:02 PM
Copyright 1997-2016, SimHQ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.6.0