Uff DBond, knowing your opinions on W3 and DOSII, and having found myself usually feeling very similar, that's not too encouraging.

What did they actually fail to get right on this title, to make it a true gem?

Is the story too meh, is the world not built well, is the gameplay loop just average, or is it technical problems that kill the experience?

BTW, I wonder how much the drama around this release will delay the Witcher 3 DX12 version. I suppose it's the same engine and a lot of the same coders involved, and yet I'm really looking forward to a visual upgrade for that game.