TLoU2 is a divisive game and those perfect score reviews were politically motivated. Very hard to trust most reviews nowadays.

Take the TV show "Orphan Black," for example, which I watched due to recommendation here. I have two episodes left, and despite the glowing reviews on IMDB--I mean, we're talking 8s, 9s and 10s, for myself is one of the weakest shows I have watched in the last five years. Very, very disappointing and frankly I could care less how they finish the mess. But, after watching the series, I can see why many of the reviews rated it so highly... And these scores have nothing to do with the quality of science fiction writing or plotting.