Originally Posted By: farokh
Originally Posted By: Hpasp
but less authentic than the Volhov.


excuse me i dont understand ... why s-300 pmu simulation can be less authentic than the Volhov.?
what about mim-104 patriot simulation ? it will be less authentic than the Volhov. too?


I can rate the simulation authenticity about the amount of information I'm aware of the system...

S-75M3 Volhov (SA-2E)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 4 points.

S-125M Neva (SA-3B)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 4 points.

KRUG (SA-4B)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 4 points.

S-200VE Vega-E (SA-5B)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 4 points.

SA-75M Dvina (SA-2F)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: NO

Altogether 2 points.

ZSU-23-4V1 Shilka
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 4 points.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Systems not simulated:

Nike Hercules
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: YES, but requires a 1000km drive...
System operators available to answer questions during development: Hopefully
Original operation documentation is available: Partially
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 3 points.

S-25M Berkut (SA-1)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: It is available at the PVO museum in Moscow, but nobody taken the required shots so far.
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: YES
Videos available showing the system operation: NO

Altogether 1,5 points.

S-60
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: It is available in Hungary, but was not able to got inside at any of it.
System operators available to answer questions during development: YES
Original operation documentation is available: NO
Videos available showing the system operation: NO

Altogether 1,5 points.

S-300PT Biryusa (SA-10A)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: It is available at the PVO museum in Moscow, but nobody taken the required shots so far.
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: NO
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 1,5 points.

S-300PMU (SA-10B)
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: NO, but can be generated digitally.
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: NO
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 1 points.

Patriot
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: NO, but can be generated digitally.
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: NO
Videos available showing the system operation: YES

Altogether 1 points.


OSA
Real system is available to photo the required screen-shots: NO
System operators available to answer questions during development: NO
Original operation documentation is available: Partially
Videos available showing the system operation: NO

Altogether 0.5 points.

Last edited by Hpasp; 02/09/13 08:40 PM.

Hpasp
Free SAM Simulator, "Realistic to the Switch"

(U-2 over Sverdlovsk, B-52's over Hanoi, F-4 Phantoms over the Sinai, F-16's and the F-117A Stealth bomber over the Balkans.)
http://sites.google.com/site/samsimulator1972/home

Book from the author - Soviet Nuclear Weapons in Hungary 1961-1991
https://sites.google.com/view/nuclear-weapons-in-hungary/

thumbsup