I've never watched "Southland" but I'm curious to know what makes this different from the tons of other cop shows that are on the air now and from those in the past.
Dunno exactly...but somehow it's a bit different. And entertaining.
I think it gives a better view into how what we the public see, vs what a cop would see. What happens 15 seconds before the Youtube video starts. What happened to the cop on a call earlier in the day.
Usually they show a scene unfolding before you, then the show starts earlier that day, or that week. Towards the end of the episode, you then can see the leadup to and including the scene shown earlier, and then the aftermath, the consequences. It's kind of like showing the politician's "sound bite", then showing the entire speech, where you may get a very different context and better understanding of what they meant and why.
It also seems to give a more "real world" idea of what detective work must be like...less "Clue/Whodunit/SherlockHolmes", and more "many random cases, most just waiting for more clues, put it together when we have more info/evidence". More cooperation and coordination with the beat cops than you normally see.
Dunno, I just think that while there are more chills and thrills than would be realistic, at least the presentation of it, and the dialogue/characters seem more real, more like what I'd expect. Good show, good dialogue, great action/shootouts, IMO better quality all 'round than most "action movies".
But bar none, the actual scenarios these cops find themselves in, in the show, seem like they were literally taken from police incident reports (maybe even LAPD), not the imaginations of some dopey writer typing on his laptop in a Starbucks sipping a latte. I'm sure the writers of this show do that too, but instead of relying solely on their imaginations, they seem to actually talk with real cops about real situations and how those actually go down. THAT is what makes this a good show IMO.