It does suffer of some flaws on its implementation mechanics...but in terms of content, it's really hard to beat.
It could be analogous to a good book that got published in a bad media. The book might be difficult to hold on to, but you just can't put it down.
Fortunately, this book can be, and it is being, improved. And I think this one is a better development platform or Oblivion and Morrowind (even if Morrowind's story and RPG'ness was better). Once the Creation Kit is released, and once the data errors (bogus quests) are fixed, this game will shine.
I personally have not found a better non-sim gaming experience this year.
That said, I would give the game of the year award to Falcon BMS instead.
