Forums » SimHQ Community » Outer Space & Science Fiction » Cargo...


Page 2 of 2 < 1 2
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
Hop to:
#3427613 - 11/06/11 11:53 AM Re: Cargo... [Re: Player]
Rick.50cal Offline
Veteran

Registered: 10/25/99
Posts: 18371
Originally Posted By: Player
For those who have seen it:
SPOILER!!


Click to reveal..
I think they only cut comunicaton in/from Rhea..not unplugged anyone. Itīs just a way to prove for people in earth, thatīs they telling the truth about Rhea.


I agree...but...

Click to reveal..

Thinking about it when they were there, about to blow it up, I thought "huh...great, so now they will be out of contact with friends and family for 8 solid years, just because these two twits wanted to prove it was virtual?!?".

After considering the need to "prove the point", it's a horribly cruel thing to do to hundreds of thousands of people, "virtual world" or not. Even judges can't prevent serial killer inmates from being visited by family members...but these two "hero" twits are going to decide that for ALL those people.

If they'd had time, and tech knowledge, they could have instead just put a shutdown timer on the array, say have it block all traffic for a month. But that wouldn't prove the people weren't on the planet living lives, just that the array was broken/destroyed, just as blowing it up wouldn't actually prove that either: a radio broadcast is a radio broadcast, and if it breaks, just means the comms is down, not that the world is virtual or not!

The home reaction won't be "oh noes! they live in a virtual world!", but instead "when are the pr1cks gonna fix the antenna so I can chat with my niece again?!?".

Otherwise a good movie though! And that shortsightedness demonstrates that even heroes aren't perfect...maybe writers too, but maybe it was intentional? Perhaps they feel regret on the ride home?!
_________________________
POLITICS, WAR, ECONOMY, CONTROVERSY! and other heated discussions and debates in the PWEC sub-forum at the bottom of this forum main page. See you there!

Top
#3431936 - 11/11/11 12:12 PM Re: Cargo... [Re: Rick.50cal]
Alicatt Online   content
Member

Registered: 05/13/10
Posts: 515
Loc: Limburg
Originally Posted By: Rick.50cal


I agree...but...

Click to reveal..

Thinking about it when they were there, about to blow it up, I thought "huh...great, so now they will be out of contact with friends and family for 8 solid years, just because these two twits wanted to prove it was virtual?!?".

After considering the need to "prove the point", it's a horribly cruel thing to do to hundreds of thousands of people, "virtual world" or not. Even judges can't prevent serial killer inmates from being visited by family members...but these two "hero" twits are going to decide that for ALL those people.

If they'd had time, and tech knowledge, they could have instead just put a shutdown timer on the array, say have it block all traffic for a month. But that wouldn't prove the people weren't on the planet living lives, just that the array was broken/destroyed, just as blowing it up wouldn't actually prove that either: a radio broadcast is a radio broadcast, and if it breaks, just means the comms is down, not that the world is virtual or not!

The home reaction won't be "oh noes! they live in a virtual world!", but instead "when are the pr1cks gonna fix the antenna so I can chat with my niece again?!?".

Otherwise a good movie though! And that shortsightedness demonstrates that even heroes aren't perfect...maybe writers too, but maybe it was intentional? Perhaps they feel regret on the ride home?!

Think you are right on the money there!

Click to reveal..
I kept thinking Alien all the way through the film but without the shock/horror. There were a few continuity errors through it as well eg. Laura's Desert Eagle became a Browning HP at one point. While I enjoyed it I'm also glad it was only Ģ6 for the Bluray.

film and sound quality was good, a sort of Blade Runner meets Alien in parts smile and the picture aspect of 2.35:1 meant I could fill my screen.
_________________________
Chlanna nan con thigibh a so's gheibh sibh feoil
Sons of the hound come here and get flesh
Clan Cameron

Top
#3433048 - 11/13/11 06:45 AM Re: Cargo... [Re: Rick.50cal]
Lipfert Offline
Member

Registered: 10/09/01
Posts: 666
Loc: Ost Front
Watched Cargo, liked it. Acting was better than expected. Had "0" expectations when I watched Pandorum, therefore I was able to get into and enjoyed it. If you set expectations for it, probably would be a fail.

However I do tend to go easy on Sci-Fi because the pickings are so slim.

I rank Cargo with Moon, Pandorum with Sunshine.
_________________________
Adjutant Lipfert 5./JG52
Combat Simulation Group "CSG", 1500+ Online DCG Missions on the Ost Front

Top
#3435808 - 11/17/11 01:19 AM Re: Cargo... [Re: Rick.50cal]
bogusheadbox Offline
Opinionated Aussie Bloke
Member

Registered: 03/14/06
Posts: 798
Well thanks for the heads up. I have just watched pandorum and without any knowledge of the film thought the start of it was a good premise. Though it ended up as a typical ..(spoiler).. It was entertaining.

So i have cargo on order and hopefully i will enjoy that one as well.

Thanks for the tip
:-)
_________________________
Why do we love a country where everthing in it can kill us (even the women)

Top
#3464883 - 11/30/11 03:10 AM Re: Cargo... [Re: Rick.50cal]
bogusheadbox Offline
Opinionated Aussie Bloke
Member

Registered: 03/14/06
Posts: 798
well i finally got to watch cargo (having trouble with Lovefilm recently), and i was impressed with it. I like the feel they gave of deep / long sapce travel and it kept the theme without going "star trek" or space horror as with other movies.

I enjoyed this more than pandorum.

Thanks again for the heads up. Good movies and good watching.
_________________________
Why do we love a country where everthing in it can kill us (even the women)

Top
Page 2 of 2 < 1 2
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
Hop to:


Forum Use Agreement | Privacy Statement | SimHQ Staff
Copyright 1997-2012, SimHQ Inc. All Rights Reserved.