It really breaks down into two destinct groups-pilots and equipment operators.
I'm not a 'real' pilot so my observations don't hold any water with some of the more elite around here... but I have always said nearly the same thing as what Copter said here.
Especially when CAPTAIN Chesley Sullenbuger put his A320, with both engines out, safely down in the Hudson River with no loss of life or serious injury. Had he followed the ATC guidance he was given (to divert to some field in New Jersey), he, his crew, and all of his passengers would be dead now.
Fortunately, Sully is a PILOT. He had the nads to
ignore ATC directives and FLY HIS PLANE, outside of any training or procedures, because there
was no training or procedure for ditching an A320 with both engines out in a river. Everyone on that plane was damned lucky that there was a PILOT on the flight deck, not a 'systems operator.'
In my lay opinion, far too many commercial "pilots" are actually systems operators. They push buttons and moves controls in accordance to the manual and rote procedural memorization. Depart from predictable conditions and procedures, and they crash. Literally.
Examples:
Colgan Air 3407 in Feb, 2009. Aerodynamic stall due to presumed icing. But it wasn't the stall that killed all onboard. It was what the systems operators who were sitting in the pilot/first officer seats
did about the stall. They did exactly what you're not supposed to do, and crashed their plane.
Air France 447 in July 2011. Apparent failure of an airspeed indicator caused autopilot failure. Fine. The autopilot can fail. That's why we put real pilots in the cockpit. Unfortunately, yet again, there were no pilots in the cockpit that night, only systems operators wearing pilot uniforms. And when the airspeed indicator failed, so did they. Not able to evaluate what was really happening to their aircraft, they (again) did exactly the wrong thing and kept pulling the nose up, worsening the stall and departure from controlled flight. There was no
procedure for what was happening, so they couldn't simply follow a memorized procedure. They needed some pilot sense, and, sadly, they were fresh out.
Yeah, I know I've hijacked the thread, but I started it, so there.
Plus, as has been pointed out by a
real pilot, the very concept of a left-handed pilot is:
UTTER NONSENSE!
