I remember a design for a two phase micro brushless motor, using the magnet from a coreless pager motor (which might be simpler to come by and should have a suitable shaft already fitted). Essentially it had two cross shaped plates at either end with four "pillars" linking them at the corners. The windings went between these pretty much the same way as in your first prototype. I did try to find the pictures, but it's most likely buried deep in the archives of rcgroups. The design has long been superseded by the single phase hall controlled motor (essentially an actuator with no rotation limits), and is mostly used for sub-gram planes. There's also brushless conversions of coreless pager motors that use the original windings, but these are three phase motors, so not really suitable to work as an instrument.
edit: Oops, I just realized I made a mistake. Coreless motors have a static magnet, so the shaft won't really be fitted to the magnet. Sorry about that. OTOH, the magnet will be a nice cylinder polarized transversally, so it ought to be still good, but the shaft will have to be fitted to it somehow.
edit2: this thread in particular:
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=596219&pp=100&page=12 might be interesting for building and winding techniques.