Seeing the very controversial BFM thread by KidVicious resurrected it seems to be a good time to post links to my recent "Guns Only" dogfighting videos I have uploaded to YouTube. I do not wish to get involved in any of the technical data discussion or controversy in that thread. So I will chime in with my own opinion on this matter and say it with video. It is through my own experience that pilot skills are always the deciding factor when fighting aircraft of equal or superior performance capabilities. I chose a very mountainous area for the making of these videos and used the terrain to my complete advantage whenever possible. Obviously I was very heavy handed on the use of the throttle, but with dogfighting in this sim its not who lands that wins, it's who remains in the air at the end. IMO its not all about the flight models, or what is or is not in RL, it is about SA and piloting skills. Historical facts prove that many times over. I recently watched a dogfight series on the History Channel, and watched A Dauntless dive bomber take on 3 or more Zeros. I am sure statistical data was the last thing on his mind. Only his wits and SA saved him. I am sure no one would have believed him given the odds, good thing his rear gunner, who was so overcome by the G's and could not even get shots off, was his witness of the totally unbelievable engagement.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZeybULmM4M F-16 VS. Mirage 2000-5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_jHLOYp16ec F-16 VS 3 F-15s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIkrtZqBkvg F-16 VS. F-22
All are guns only, with limited fuel and ammo.